Do higher fulvic acid percentages mean better Shilajit?

Not necessarily. Higher percentages don't automatically indicate better quality, particularly when different testing methods are used. Even a genuine lab certificate can be misleading if the findings are misunderstood or used to support claims that the analysis doesn't establish.

 

Spend a little time comparing Shilajit products and you'll probably notice that the numbers have become almost as important as the resin itself. Fulvic acid percentages are displayed prominently, mineral concentrations are quoted as evidence of quality, and lab certificates have become an increasingly familiar part of the sales pitch. Some brands now go further, advertising molecular weights, dibenzo-α-pyrone concentrations and other measurements that most customers are unlikely to have encountered before. This growing interest in testing is, for the most part, a good thing. Shilajit is a complicated natural material, and proper analytical testing can tell us a great deal that its appearance, texture or geographical origin can't. But there's a problem with the way these figures are increasingly being used. A number on a certificate might be perfectly genuine without supporting the conclusion a brand has drawn from it, and some of the claims now appearing in Shilajit marketing raise fairly basic questions about whether the businesses promoting them understand what their tests actually measure.

Why Shilajit has become a numbers game

Part of the difficulty comes from the way the market has developed. As Shilajit has become more widely available, consumers have quite reasonably started asking more demanding questions. They want to know whether a product has been tested for heavy metals, whether the fulvic acid content has been independently verified and whether there's any evidence behind the claims being made. Not so long ago, an attractive story about the Himalayas might have been enough to persuade somebody to buy a jar. Today, a certificate showing 70% fulvic acid can appear considerably more convincing, particularly when another brand is advertising 40%. But once customers begin treating those percentages as a measure of quality, brands have an obvious incentive to produce the largest number they can. When high fulvic acid percentages become commonplace, the pressure shifts towards finding something else to measure, preferably something that makes a product appear different from everything else on the market. What began as a sensible demand for better evidence can gradually become a competition over who has the most impressive figures.

There's nothing particularly surprising about businesses responding to what their customers want, and more extensive testing should be encouraged where it provides useful information. The difficulty is that Shilajit's chemistry doesn't lend itself particularly well to the simple comparisons that marketing tends to favour. It's a heterogeneous mixture of organic substances and minerals, with a composition that can vary according to its source, geological history and processing. Even something as apparently straightforward as fulvic acid concentration involves analytical decisions that can have a substantial influence on the result. As explained in our guide to fulvic acid testing, different methods don't necessarily measure the same fractions, and two certificates reporting very different percentages may not be directly comparable. ISO 19822:2018, for example, provides a defined procedure for determining humic acids and hydrophobic fulvic acids in certain materials, including geological deposits. It's a useful method for investigating those fractions, but it doesn't establish whether a Shilajit product is better than another, or whether the substances it contains will produce particular effects in the body. Those are different questions, although the distinction isn't always apparent when the final result is reduced to a percentage on a website.

Can fulvic acid really have a molecular weight below 500 Da?

More recently, another claim has appeared in Shilajit marketing: that fulvic acid has a molecular weight below 500 Daltons, with its supposedly small size allowing it to be readily absorbed by the body. It's an interesting statement, partly because it sounds so specific. Daltons are a legitimate unit of molecular mass, and the suggestion that smaller molecules may be more easily absorbed has a degree of plausibility. The trouble begins with the description of fulvic acid itself. Unlike caffeine, which is an individual compound with a defined molecular mass of approximately 194 Daltons, fulvic acid isn't one molecule. It's a chemically diverse fraction of naturally occurring organic material, containing numerous molecular species with different structures and masses. The composition of that fraction can vary considerably depending on where the material originated and how it was isolated. There is no universally established molecular weight of less than 500 Da that can simply be attributed to fulvic acid as a whole. Presenting the figure as though it were an inherent property of fulvic acid gives the impression of a precisely defined chemical substance when the reality is considerably more complicated.

Researchers have been investigating this complexity for years, using techniques capable of examining molecular constituents in far greater detail than conventional concentration testing. A 2007 study published in Water Research, for example, used size-exclusion chromatography coupled with Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR-MS) to investigate differences in the molecular composition of fulvic acid fractions. Such research has shown that fulvic acids contain many different molecular species rather than one uniform compound, although the results depend on the material being examined and the techniques used. There are legitimate ways to estimate average molecular masses and investigate molecular-mass distributions, but they require an appropriate method and an explanation of what the resulting numbers represent. A measured average below 500 Da wouldn't establish that every constituent falls below that mass, any more than a distribution of detected ions could necessarily provide a complete inventory of everything present in the original material. And research on fulvic acid isolated from river water shouldn't automatically be treated as an exact description of the fulvic fraction in Himalayan Shilajit. The findings are relevant to understanding the chemistry, but they don't provide every commercial preparation with the same molecular characteristics.

To support a claim about the molecular mass of a particular fulvic acid preparation, a lab would need to undertake the appropriate molecular characterisation, potentially using techniques such as FT-ICR-MS, Orbitrap high-resolution mass spectrometry or size-exclusion chromatography. These methods can provide useful information, although each has limitations, and a meaningful report would need to identify the sample preparation, analytical method and basis of the reported result. Even then, the finding wouldn't automatically establish absorption. Molecular size can influence whether substances cross biological membranes, but it isn't the only factor involved. Chemical structure, solubility, electrical charge, digestion and metabolism all play a part, and different constituents within a complex mixture may behave differently. A substance can dissolve in water without being absorbed into the bloodstream, just as something can cross the intestinal wall without necessarily reaching a particular tissue. We've examined these complications more fully in our article on what the body actually absorbs from Shilajit. For the present claim, the more immediate concern is that an apparently precise molecular-weight figure is being used to support an additional biological conclusion, when neither the meaning of the figure nor its relevance to absorption has been adequately established.

What does a DBP percentage actually measure?

Another example concerns dibenzo-α-pyrones, usually abbreviated to DBPs. These compounds have attracted interest in Shilajit research, particularly in discussions of antioxidant activity and mitochondrial function. During a recent approach from a supplier offering Shilajit in bulk, a certificate was provided that listed DBPs at 3–7%, with HPLC-DAD given as the analytical method. HPLC-DAD, or high-performance liquid chromatography with diode-array detection, is a perfectly legitimate technique, and there's nothing inherently implausible about using it to investigate particular DBPs. What was less clear was how the lab had arrived at a collective percentage for the entire chemical family, particularly one expressed as a range rather than a specific result for the batch concerned. DBPs aren't one substance any more than fulvic acid is one molecule. They're a family of structurally related compounds, and although particular members can be identified and quantified, the term itself doesn't tell us which compounds have been included in a measurement.

Two of the better-known examples discussed in Shilajit research are urolithin A and urolithin B, which have defined chemical structures and can be investigated using suitable analytical methods and reference standards. But measuring those two compounds wouldn't necessarily establish the concentration of every DBP that might be present. When we asked Marek, the analytical chemist we work with on our Shilajit testing, about measuring DBPs, he explained that he could arrange testing for urolithin A and urolithin B individually, with each result reported separately in milligrams per kilogram, but couldn't measure the entire DBP family collectively using the methods available to his lab. He also cautioned that the presence of these compounds in a particular Shilajit sample shouldn't simply be assumed, since the published research remains limited and sometimes inconsistent. That seems a reasonable starting point. Before assigning a concentration to a collection of compounds, it would be useful to establish which of them are actually present and whether the method can distinguish and quantify them reliably. The chemistry and testing difficulties are explored in more detail in our article on dibenzo-α-pyrones in Shilajit.

There is a qualification here, however, because collective DBP measurements aren't entirely without precedent. A 2016 clinical study published in Andrologia described a standardised Shilajit preparation containing not less than 0.3% dibenzo-α-pyrones, quantified using HPLC with reference standards isolated from Shilajit extract. So it would be wrong to suggest that no lab can produce a meaningful collective DBP result. What the study doesn't establish is that every certificate reporting a DBP percentage is measuring the same collection of compounds or using an equivalent method. A properly defined collective result might be entirely legitimate, provided it's clear which substances are included, how they're measured and how the final percentage is calculated. Without that information, a figure described simply as total DBPs is difficult to interpret. It may represent the sum of several identified compounds, an estimate expressed relative to one reference standard or a differently defined fraction. Those aren't necessarily interchangeable measurements, and treating them as though they were could produce comparisons that have little scientific meaning.

The reported range of 3–7% raises a separate question. A lab certificate can legitimately include specification limits, expected ranges or measurement uncertainty, but those aren't the same as a measured concentration for a particular sample. If a manufacturer specifies that its material should contain between 3% and 7% of a particular group of compounds, that may be a reasonable purchasing specification, assuming the compounds and method are properly defined. It doesn't tell us what concentration was actually found in the batch being offered for sale. Nor does a broad range automatically represent measurement uncertainty. The figure might have an entirely reasonable explanation, but without seeing the underlying method and supporting results, it's difficult to know what the certificate establishes. That doesn't prove the document is false or that the lab didn't perform an analysis. It does mean the number shouldn't be accepted as evidence of a measured batch-specific DBP concentration without further clarification. If a business intends to use such a result to demonstrate the quality of its Shilajit, understanding that distinction seems a reasonable place to start.

The question of what a certificate actually establishes extends beyond the chemistry itself. Lab accreditation, for example, is often treated as an assurance that every result on a report has been independently verified to the same standard. In practice, a laboratory may be accredited under ISO/IEC 17025 for certain methods while performing other analyses outside its accredited scope. That doesn't automatically make those additional tests invalid, but the accreditation status of the particular analysis should be clear. The identity of the sample matters too. A genuine report may describe material supplied by a manufacturer or wholesaler without establishing that it represents the finished jars eventually sold to customers. There are also differences between a measured result, a specification, a detection limit and an estimate, all of which can appear on technical documents without necessarily being understood by the person reading them. These are among the reasons we've encouraged customers to look beyond the headline figures when reading a Shilajit lab report. The certificate is useful evidence, but its usefulness depends on knowing which questions the testing was designed to answer.

When a lab result becomes a marketing claim

Not every questionable scientific claim begins with somebody trying to deceive customers. There is another explanation that may be rather more common. Many businesses entering the Shilajit market have little formal knowledge of analytical chemistry, and there's no particular reason why somebody selling a supplement should already understand chromatography, molecular-mass distributions or the complexities of humic substances. The difficulty comes when that lack of knowledge is combined with an unquestioning reliance on lab reports. A brand might commission testing in good faith, receive a certificate containing unfamiliar terminology and apparently precise figures, and assume the lab has established considerably more than it actually has. A measurement of selected compounds can become a statement about an entire chemical family. An estimated molecular mass can be presented as a fixed property of fulvic acid, which is then used to suggest that the product is readily absorbed. By the time those claims appear on a website, the original qualifications may have disappeared. The business might genuinely believe it's communicating reliable scientific information, even when its interpretation has gone well beyond what was measured.

Labs have a responsibility here too. If a certificate uses an inadequately defined parameter, presents a specification range without explaining what it represents or provides too little information about the method, the company commissioning the analysis may struggle to interpret it correctly. That doesn't necessarily mean the analysis itself was poorly conducted, but communication is part of what makes testing useful. Equally, a brand can't reasonably assume that anything printed on a certificate can be repeated in its marketing without further thought. If a result is going to be used to persuade customers that one product is better than another, the business should be able to explain what was measured and why the comparison is justified. Sometimes that will mean going back to the lab, asking for clarification or seeking advice from somebody who understands the analytical method. None of those steps is particularly unreasonable, especially when the alternative is to publish claims that customers have little opportunity to investigate for themselves.

The growing demand for impressive figures is making this more complicated. Once a particular percentage becomes familiar, a higher one can seem like an obvious improvement, even when the methods aren't comparable or the increase has little established relevance to quality. Brands may then look for other constituents to measure, hoping to demonstrate something that their competitors can't. Molecular weight and DBPs are particularly attractive for this purpose because the terminology sounds sophisticated, while relatively few consumers will know how such measurements should be performed or interpreted. Some of the resulting testing may be genuinely valuable, and better chemical characterisation of Shilajit would be welcome. But commercial pressure can also encourage businesses to search for a marketable number before they've established whether the measurement will answer a useful question. A technically authentic certificate doesn't necessarily solve that problem. It can just as easily give an unsupported interpretation an appearance of scientific authority.

These expectations apply to One Life Foods as much as to any other brand. The business publishes its testing methods and available results, including fulvic and humic acid concentrations, elemental profiles and contaminant screening. Different origins produce different results, and those differences don't always point towards one obvious measure of superiority. A higher fulvic acid percentage may accompany a lower humic acid concentration or a different measured mineral profile, while the nature and extent of testing can vary between batches. Customers can compare those differences across the Shilajit range, but the figures still require interpretation. They describe particular measurements on particular samples rather than providing a definitive ranking of every aspect of the products. Publishing results also means accepting that methods, reporting practices and earlier interpretations may need to be revisited as better information becomes available. Any business encouraging customers to question scientific claims elsewhere in the market ought to be prepared for the same questions about its own.

It's worth remembering what customers were originally asking for when they began demanding better testing. Most wanted reassurance that the Shilajit they were buying was genuine, appropriately processed and screened for relevant contaminants. Those remain sensible priorities, and in many cases they're more directly useful than an impressive molecular-weight claim or an unexplained percentage for a group of compounds that hasn't been properly defined. A certificate showing acceptable levels of specified contaminants tells us something relevant about the sample's safety profile, although it can't establish everything about the finished product. Reliable traceability helps establish whether a result applies to the material being sold. A clearly identified analytical method allows meaningful comparisons to be made, provided the samples and reporting bases are sufficiently similar. None of these things is especially glamorous, and they don't always produce the kind of headline figure that looks good on a product page. But they're the sorts of questions that testing can answer with a reasonable degree of confidence.

There's still plenty to learn about Shilajit, and more sophisticated analysis may help researchers understand its chemistry considerably better than they do today. It would be a shame if the industry's enthusiasm for numbers discouraged that work, or if every new measurement were dismissed simply because somebody had used it carelessly in their marketing. The more immediate concern is that the growing appetite for scientific proof may be encouraging businesses to make claims they don't fully understand, while customers are left to assume that a lab certificate must establish everything printed alongside it. Better testing is worth pursuing, but so is a better understanding of its limitations. Otherwise, the industry risks becoming increasingly proficient at producing impressive-looking figures without becoming much better at explaining what those figures mean.

Written By

Written by Chris Simon, Founder of One Life Foods.

Chris has worked in the supplement industry since 2009 and is known for seeking out exceptional ingredients, products and formulations.

Read more about Chris and the story behind One Life Foods.

Latest Learnings

View all

Scientist using a pipette during chemical analysis in a lab.

Shilajit’s Numbers Problem: When Lab Testing Becomes a Marketing Tool

As consumers demand higher fulvic acid percentages and increasingly detailed lab reports, Shilajit brands are under pressure to produce ever more impressive numbers. But do those figures actually mean what customers think they do? From questionable molecular-weight claims to poorly defined DBP measurements, we examine how genuine testing can lead to misleading conclusions when the science behind it isn’t properly understood.

Read moreabout Shilajit’s Numbers Problem: When Lab Testing Becomes a Marketing Tool

Black and white goat with large curved horns resting in straw at a Cotswolds farm

Can Supplements Help Injury Recovery? My Run-In with Lucifer in the Cotswolds

What do a suspicious-looking goat called Lucifer, a badly injured ankle and a cupboard full of supplements have in common? More than I'd have liked, apparently.

After an unfortunate incident in the Cotswolds, I decided to investigate whether nutrition and supplements could play a meaningful role in injury recovery. From collagen and vitamin C to creatine, citrulline and Shilajit, I look at the science behind the ingredients I've been taking, what I've experienced so far, and whether any of it is actually making a difference.

Read moreabout Can Supplements Help Injury Recovery? My Run-In with Lucifer in the Cotswolds

Abstract magnified representation of dark Shilajit resin dispersing into water, with swirling brown plumes and suspended particles.

“50% Fulvic Acid”: 50% of What? How to Compare Shilajit Lab Results Properly

A Shilajit laboratory report can be technically correct and still give consumers the wrong impression. A claimed 50% fulvic acid doesn't necessarily mean 50% of the resin in the jar. We explain dry-basis versus as-is results, why testing methods matter, and why we believe as-is reporting is the more transparent approach.

Read moreabout “50% Fulvic Acid”: 50% of What? How to Compare Shilajit Lab Results Properly